Oh, shit, a supermutant! Forget my minigun, I need something with real power…a hunting rifle!”
You probably know that I’ve been doing a long series on the Elder Scrolls series. I’d had to put that aside for a little bit, since I’d been playing Morrowind on a nice PC that, sadly, I don’t (can’t) use anymore. I have access to a PS3 right now, and I’ve been playing some console stuff…but none of it really fit into that framework.
Then I tried out Fallout 3. Finally. After all these years.
It’s like I never stopped. For better or worse, Fallout 3 really, really feels like an old-style total conversion of the post-Daggerfall Elder Scrolls games.
Sure, there are no knights and demons and whatnot, but that’s not what Elder Scrolls’ gameplay flow, the experience, had ever been about. the Elder Scrolls had always been about other things.
- It’d been about exploring the countryside, and carefully mapping out the ruins of ancient civilizations contained therein.
- It’d been about encountering bandits and monsters, and either getting the drop on them or fleeing in terror if they got the drop on you.
- It’d been about making choices for how you want to handle your problems, being given quests that end up testing your moral outlook, and getting a wee bit frustrated when you ran across a problem that your specific skill choices just wouldn’t allow you to solve.
- It’s about plumbing the history of a bizarre environment, and peeling back the layers of worldbuilding only to find yet more layers.
THAT is Elder Scrolls. And, yes, THAT is Fallout 3. Same damned thing.
For those about to grab their pitchforks, though…that isn’t a bad thing. I was never really that attached to the old Fallout games, but I knew enough about them to realize that they were themselves a conversion of the sort of gameplay that you’d find in an old top-down RPG in the vein of Planescape:Torment or Baldur’s Gate. You had turns and squares and stats and countryside and towns and encounters and all of that. Sure, it had guns and rads, but it also had everything else that’s defined that genre since the Gold Box games.
Remember, genres in games have absolutely nothing to do with setting. You can have a fantasy shooter like Panzer Dragoon, a steampunk FPS like The Order: 1886, or a historical sandbox like Assassin’s Creed 2. The setting genre and the game genre are only connected if you want them to be connected.
So, before you get all shouty, think about it. So what if Fallout 3 is basically an Elder Scrolls game? It’s still an RPG. It’s just a different kind of RPG.
All that said…there’s still VATS. And, yeah, VATS is the one thing that makes modern Fallout weird. More in the next post. I guess the series is back on. It’s just taking a bit of a radioactive detour.